The Definitive Guide to Living in the Capital , Cairo , Egypt

The Best of Me

The Best of Me: Overly Sentimental Nicholas Sparks Adaptation

  • James MarsdenLiana Liberato...
  • Romance
  • Michael Hoffman
reviewed by
Marija Loncarevic
rate it
review it
The Best of Me: Overly Sentimental Nicholas Sparks Adaptation

Love him or hate him, one thing is for certain; Nicholas Sparks always delivers. What exactly it is he delivers is another story altogether and the critics will have a field day taking shots at the latest film to be adapted from the American writer’s pages, The Best of Me; a sappy and an overly sentimental drama that plays with the notion of fate and destiny in the most ridiculous of ways.   

Jumping head-first into what has become an extremely tired formula, The Best of Me is centred on Dawson Cole (Marsden); a rugged Louisiana oil rigger who, after learning of the death of a close friend – and surrogate father – Tuck Hostetler (McRanney), is summoned to return home to fulfil his friend’s last dying wishes.

Dawson, who is still recovering from a near-death experience, is surprised to learn that Amanda Collier (Monoghan) – his teenage sweetheart whom he’s been pining for the last couple of decades – has also been asked to tend to Tuck’s last requests.  Stumped and completely thrown by this chance encounter, the pair soon head off together to Tuck’s old lake house, an enchanting home that he once built for his late wife, to pack up what is left of his things and spread his ashes.

Naturally, it doesn’t take long before the sparks begin to fly and memories begin flooding back; will the long-lost lovers find their way back into each other’s arms or will fate have something else in store for them?


One of the film’s biggest problems – and distractions – is its questionable casting.  Marsden and Monoghan share very little chemistry and fail to come across as a couple madly in love while the younger versions of their characters – played by Bracey and Liberato respectively – shared little-to-no physical resemblance to their older-selves. Granted, any film demands a certain degree of suspension of disbelief, but how about we get some help with that one in a while?    

Ineptly adapted by J. Millis Goodloe and Will Fetters, the story – in true Nicholas Sparks fashion – runs in two simultaneous timelines and, while the cinematography is pretty decent – plenty of sun-kissed scenes to keep the romantics in the audience content – there are just too many clichés and too much insufferable dialogue.

All things considered, The Best of Me is ironically, one of the worst Nicholas Spark’s adaptations to date; it’s corny in the sloppiest of ways and seems a little too desperate please. 

Like This? Try

The Notebook (2004), Safe Haven (2013), Dear John (2010)

360 Tip

The late Paul Walker was initially cast in the lead role before his untimely death.

Write your review

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.